What are you looking for?

Top 10 time-tested lures

These lures still catch fish today just as reliably as they did when they first hit tackle boxes decades ago.

In a rapidly evolving market driven by the next big thing, fishing lures of yesteryear tend to get buried in tackle boxes. There rest classic lures that have withstood the test of time. Baits that helped define a technique or became synonymous with a certain species. These were baits that changed the game. Baits that were inherited from a par­ent or grandparent. Baits that even the most seasoned anglers con­sider ‘old-school.’ These 10 baits are still relevant today. Arbogast Jitterbug Origin: Developed in Ohio, USA in 1939 Category: Topwater Lure maker Fred Arbogast has several lures to his name but none more well-known than the Jitterbug. The original prototype came from carving a section of broom handle and attaching a piece of a spoon on the front. With some tinkering and refined adjustments, Arbogast crafted a lure that became equally unique and effective. Few topwater baits are as recognizable as the Jitterbug and the same can be said of its tell-tale plop-plop-plop sound. The characteristic large metal lip on the face of the Jitterbug gives the bait action and its recognizable appear­ance. The size and double-cupped shape of the lip cause the bait to wobble from side-to-side on a steady retrieve as the corners of the lip alternate dipping in the water. For a time during the Second World War, Jitterbugs were constructed with plastic lips due to shortages of aluminum. Jitterbugs have been catching bass since their incep­tion more than 80 years ago and continue to be a topwater favourite of both bass and bass anglers. Mr. Twister Curly Tail Grub Origin: Developed in Louisiana, USA in 1972 Category: Soft plastic Arguably the most cost-effective lure money can buy. A grub paired with a jig head can catch a lot of fish. And that’s exactly what these infamous soft baits have been doing since they hit the market 50 years ago. Before the Curly Tail Grub, soft baits were more rigid and lacked action. It’s the unwavering swimming action of the Mr. Twister tail that makes it a target for virtually every fish. Curly Tail Grubs are easy to fish. Use a slow, straight retrieve, or hop it along bottom, or jig it vertically. Curly Tails are the champion of fly-in fishing trips, eliminat­ing the need for live bait. Attaching one to a spoon’s treble hook is a common tactic for pike. The Len Thompson Spoon Origin: Abernethy, Saskatchewan

Want to continue reading?



Please log into your OFAH Community account to access this content. Not an OFAH member or Ontario OUT of DOORS Subscriber? Follow the links below to join or subscribe and gain access to exclusive online content.

Related Stories

Water levels in the Great Lakes have sharply declined from record highs a few years ago to below-average conditions as of mid-November.
The Jan.-Feb. 2026 digital issue of Ontario Out of Doors magazine is now available. Become a member today for your digital access.
A working carbon monoxide (CO) alarm is now required on every level of any residence with a fuel-burning appliance as of January 1, 2026.
The January 2026 solunar calendar is now available! Get the dates and times when fish and wildlife will be most active this month.
Ontario Out of Doors (OOD) is a finalist in two categories, Best Patriotic Story and Best Lifestyle Article, in the 2025 Canadian Online Publishing Awards (COPA).
The 2026 Ontario Fishing Regulations Summary, which comes into effect January 1, is now available as a downloadable PDF.