I was in my favourite stand overlooking the field where I’ve shot every decent buck in the past 10 years. It was mid-morning in early November, and across the field in the poplars, chaos was unfolding.
Not 50 yards into the bush, something wild was happening. Two mature bucks were locked in an all-out war. Antlers crashed. Branches snapped. The woods echoed with grunts and heavy breathing. I could hear the raw intensity, each sound sending a jolt of adrenaline through me.
When the noise finally settled, I waited a beat, then decided to make a call — few subtle rattles, just enough to stir curiosity. Then I dropped the antlers, gripped the stock, and scanned the trees. Moments later, a buck stepped out. I’ll never know if he was the victor or the loser — but he was the final chapter to a morning I won’t forget.
As the rut ramps up, dominance must be established. The bigger, stronger buck gets to breed receptive does — and every buck wants to be that one.
What many hunters overlook, however, is that buck-on-buck interaction doesn’t always begin with all-out brawls. It starts earlier in the season with something subtler: sparring.
Sparring usually happens early in the season. It’s a low-stakes, almost respectful interaction — a pre-season scrimmage where bucks size each other up and sort out their place in the local hierarchy.
Come late October into November, that gentlemanly tone disappears. Now it’s all-out war. These are fights that leave scars — or worse. Bucks battle hard, and it can get loud, violent, and unpredictable. This is when rattling becomes one of your most effective calls.
I like to start rattling well before the rut peaks. In early October, I mimic sparring — short, light, non-threatening sessions. Just a gentle tickle of the antlers, simulating a couple of bucks testing each other.
This kind of subtle rattling won’t pull a buck in on a string like a November brawl might, but it piques curiosity. Any deer nearby may come in to investigate.
As Halloween approaches, I turn up the volume. By late October, I’m rattling more aggressively, mimicking real conflict. From that point through mid-to late November, I go all in — hard antler crashes, raking brush, kicking leaves, even snapping the odd branch. I want it to sound like two 200-pound brutes are trying to kill each other.
This is the time to be loud and convincing — bucks are wired to respond to that kind of challenge during the peak rut.
Lately, I’ve noticed rattling doesn’t work like it used to, especially where deer numbers are down. I believe it comes down to the buck-to-doe ratio.
When does significantly outnumber bucks, competition drops. Bucks don’t need to fight as hard — or at all — to breed. Less competition means fewer reasons to charge into a fight.
In areas with a balanced herd and strong buck competition, rattling remains an excellent tactic. In lower-density areas, it can still work — but you’ll need to be more strategic. Combine it with scents, doe bleats, or decoys to increase your odds.
Rattling isn’t without risks. It’s an aggressive tactic that might spook subordinate bucks — or even mature bucks that have been through one too many battles. It’s not a silver bullet. But if you’ve ever smashed antlers together and watched a bristled-up buck stomp in, ready to fight, you know how addictive it can be.
Knowing when to spar and when to go all out is the key to rattling success. Match your approach to the rut phase and local deer behaviour. Early season? Keep it light and subtle. Late October through November? Turn up the heat.
A better way to rattle from a tree stand. See “Drop-rope rattling” in the 2023-2024 Hunting Annual: digital.oodmag.com
Originally published in the Nov.-Dec. 2025 issue of Ontario Out of Doors
Contact Information
PO Box 2800 / 4601 Guthrie Dr.
Peterborough, Ontario Canada K9J 8L5
Phone: 705-748-OFAH (6324)
Fax: 705-748-9577
Join Our Newsletter
Watch
Shop
Follow
